Department of the Environment

About us | Contact us | Publications

Settlements Header ImageSettlements Header ImageSettlements Header Image

Environment industries archive

Disclaimer

Key departmental publications, e.g. annual reports, budget papers and program guidelines are available in our online archive.

Much of the material listed on these archived web pages has been superseded, or served a particular purpose at a particular time. It may contain references to activities or policies that have no current application. Many archived documents may link to web pages that have moved or no longer exist, or may refer to other documents that are no longer available.

Bailey Motors and Panel Works Pty Ltd
Cleaner Production - Solvent Recovery Unit

This case study is no longer current with respect to the Company's business activities and operations and was not updated in the review of 2001, but is retained for informational, educational and historical purposes

Bailey Motors and Panel Works Pty Ltd has installed a small solvent recovery unit to reclaim solvent from waste paint and equipment cleaning operations. The reclaimed solvent is used for equipment cleaning and has resulted in savings from both reduced raw solvent purchases and reduced waste disposal costs.

Background

Bailey Motors and Panel Works Pty Ltd operates a panel repair workshop in Melbourne's inner city suburbs. Activities include panel repair, paint stripping, and respraying of repairs.

The Process

The excisting process generated significant quantities of solvent and paint waste from spraying operations. The paint colour 'Recipe Book' used by Bailey Motors specifies the quantities of different base colours required to make up any colour. By following the recipe, the minimum amount of paint that could be made up was 250 mL, regardless of whether less than this was required for a particular job. In addition, waste solvent was also generated from cleaning of equipment.

Three different grades of solvent were used:

Each of these solvents was purchased new, used and then disposed of by a specialist waste disposal company using incineration. The disposal cost was $80 per 60 litres.

Cleaner Production Initiative

The company purchased a small solvent recovery unit, which recovers solvent from the surplus paints left over from spraying operations. The unit consists of a boiler pot, combined with a water cooled condenser to recover clean solvent. As the recovered solvent was a mixture of 'Grade A' and 'Midway' thinners, it could not be used for viscosity adjustment in either top coats or undercoats and primers. It could, however, be used for equipment cleanup.

The Recyclene-R2 recovery unit

The Recylene-R2 recovery unit is a batch unit with a capacity of approximately 20 litres. A dried solid residue, principally containing paint pigments, remains at the end of the distillation cycle. This material is then removed, bagged and disposed of with the general rubbish. The recovery unit was purchased for approximately $6,000.


Advantages of the Process

The advantage of this initiative was that it eliminated the need to purchase new 'Gunwash' solvent for equipment cleanup. More 'Gunwash' quality solvent was being recovered from the panel shop operations than could be used for equipment cleanup, so the excess was sold to other panel shops for $40 per 60 litre drum.

The initial cost savings were significant, with elimination of waste disposal charges for waste solvent/paint, savings of $70 per 100 litres for gunwash solvent and additional income from the sale of reclaimed solvent to other panel shops. Since that time the economic savings have fallen due to the reduction in purchase price of new gunwash solvents and the uptake of the reclaiming technology by other panel shops. This has reduced the sales of reclaimed solvent by Bailey Motors. An excess of reclaimed solvents is now being generated, which is currently being stored on-site.

Economic Benefit

Costs $6,000
Annual Savings $3,600
Payback period 1.7 years

Cleaner Production Incentive

The costs associated with the purchase of new solvent and the disposal of waste solvent were the primary driving force for purchasing the solvent recovery unit. By installing the recovery equipment and minimising the disposal of waste solvent Bailey Motors were able to improve their profit margin.

Barriers

Bailey Motors did not experience any barriers in the implementation of the recovery unit.

Date of implementation: 1996.
Case Study Prepared: January 1997 by ACCP
Last reviewed: June 2001.

ACCP logo